Ripon Forum


Vol. 58, No. 5

View Print Edition

In This Edition

With over 14 million Americans currently caring for a veteran or military service member in the United States, the 6th Annual Veteran Day Special Edition of The Ripon Forum examines the challenges facing these hidden heroes and what policymakers can do to support them.

“It’s a Day When I Reflect Upon What Made My Own Service so Meaningful.”

With shaven heads and fresh uniforms, we each sworn the same oath to support and defend the United States. In that moment, our differences faded away.

“Being a veteran means being a part of something bigger than yourself.”

No matter their background, whenever I speak to a fellow veteran there is a glimmer of recognition that can only come from our shared service.

“Honoring Our Brothers and Sisters Who Made the Ultimate Sacrifice.”

As a combat veteran myself, I know the sacrifices made, the courage shown, and the dedication it takes to serve.

America’s Hidden Heroes

There are over 14 million military & veteran caregivers in the United States in the U.S. And according to the CEO of the Dole Foundation, they need our help.

Safeguarding Sacrifice: Improving Military Quality of Life

The Co-Chairs of the Armed Services Committee’s Military Quality of Life Panel discuss the bipartisan effort they are leading to make sure our troops have the resources they need off the battlefield to take care of their families and themselves.

Rebuilding Integrity and Trust at VA

Recent instances of mismanagement have left veterans waiting for services and highlight the need for greater accountability within VA.

Comprehensive Support, Data Hold Answers to Veteran Suicide Crisis

Military families make unimaginable sacrifices on behalf of our nation, and it is our responsibility to ensure we provide for their basic needs.

SkillBridge is a Win for Veterans, a Win for Business, and a Win for America

Military service creates unparalleled opportunities for young Americans. Whether you serve in the infantry, fix jets, or provide supportive services, the military teaches young men and women how to think critically, be effective leaders, embrace change, and work as a team. These skillsets are becoming more and more valuable to corporate America. Over the last […]

Beyond “Thank You for Your Service”

Veterans face conflicting perceptions, on the one hand seen as being prone to violence, on the other hand seen as a hero and placed on a pedestal.

Beyond the Uniform

In 2010, a Marine Corps veteran saw the destruction caused by the Haiti earthquake and felt compelled to help. He, along with seven others, saw an opportunity to use their skills in a time of need and took the initiative to organize and deploy, aiding hundreds of the injured. Fifteen years later, this group has […]

Should Military Commissaries be Privatized? Yes…

It it will better serve our troops and their families

Should Military Commissaries be Privatized? No…

For struggling military families, commissaries are more important than ever

Ripon Profile of Tony Gonzales

The Representative of Texas’ 23rd Congressional District and Co-Chair of the For Country Caucus discusses how his service in uniform has shaped his career.

Should Military Commissaries be Privatized? No…

… for struggling military families, commissaries are more important than ever

Privatizing the U.S. Department of Defense (DoD) commissary system has been a recurring topic since I sat on the Defense Commissary Agency’s (DeCA) Board of Directors from 2016 to 2020, then as DeCA’s CEO from 2020 to 2023.  During my tenure as CEO, we reversed a decade long 5 percent per year slide in annual revenue to a 12 percent annual revenue growth.  As we predicted, the privatization idea resurfaced with the better revenue numbers…and here we are. 

DeCA’s mission is to provide high-quality, low-priced grocery items to military families, improving their quality of life while their loved ones defend our freedom.  The commissary system provides a safe, reliable source of food, regardless of where military families may be serving.  It’s a great mission and helps these families have a taste of home, with local specialties as well, at low cost. 

DeCAs mission is to provide high-quality, low-priced, grocery items to military families, improving their quality of life while their loved ones defend our freedom.

Let me say up front that privatizing commissaries is, quite simply, a bad idea. First and foremost, it will remove a vital benefit that improves military families’ quality of life, positively impacting recruiting and retention of our military and improving our national security. Secondly, it’s a bad business decision – there is just no way the current commissary system can be as good

First, let me delve into the value of the commissary benefit – I’m an “Army Brat”, who’s dad was a 100 percent disabled career Non-Commissioned Officer (NCO) that fought in both Korea and Vietnam.  When I was growing up in the 1970’s, our only income was my dad’s salary as a Sergeant.  My mom dragged my sister and me to our commissary every week, passing four grocery stores along the way – I hated that trip!  But when I whined about it, she told me we had to shop the commissary to save money, so we could afford other things.  The money we saved at the commissary improved our quality of life…period.  And for struggling military families today, particularly lower-ranked Service Members with families and no disposable income, it is more important than ever.  The benefit today saves a military family over 25 percent on their grocery bill (verified independently), compared to buying the same items from commercial stores.  On a $300/week grocery bill, that’s $75 back in their pocket each week – nearly $4000 in annual savings! 

How is this possible in the very competitive grocery industry, where margins are razor thin?  I’ll tell you how – Congress funds most of DeCA’s operating costs, about $1.4B per year, for expenses like payroll, transportation, and utilities.  This funding allows DeCA to sell most products at prices well below commercial stores.  A private company must recover these costs through higher prices. 

From a business perspective, that last point is critical and truly makes privatization illogical, unless the intent is to remove the benefit from the military compensation package.  If a private company took control of the 235 commissaries around the world, they would either lose significant revenue if they maintained the savings, or dramatically increase prices to cover their costs. 

The benefit today saves a military family over 25 percent on their grocery bill, compared to buying the same items from commercial stores. On a $300 per week grocery bill, that is $75 back in their pocket each week – or nearly $4,000 in annual savings!

Although commissaries today operate much like a commercial grocery chain, they have many governmental constraints that prevent them from operating with the same efficiency as a commercial business.  Here are several examples that you will not hear from those advocating privatization:

First, DeCA must authenticate every customer as an authorized shopper – our veterans and military servicemembers earn the right to shop the commissary with their service to our great nation. This authentication requires DeCA’s business system to be on the DoD Information Network, subject to stringent cyber security requirements. A private company would have to invest heavily to modify their business system to meet these requirements.

Second, DeCA operates 235 stores, many in foreign countries and many in very remote locations. No business would keep all these stores open from a business perspective. Some just don’t warrant the operating costs given their limited sales. As CEO, when I was pressed to lower operating costs, I created a list of 15 stores I wanted to close, which would have had minimal impact on military families. Both Congress and DoD leaders would not allow me to close those stores due to the limited but important value they did bring to local customers, including retirees and veterans. I certainly understood and agreed with their decision, and frankly the entire exercise helped me defend the cost of the benefit.

Let me end with the most important reason why the commissary system should remain a part of the DoD — DeCA’s return on investment (ROI) is remarkable. In fact, it is the only benefit in the military system that pays for itself. In FY23, DeCA received $1.421 billion in funding and had sales of $4.6 billion, with a measured savings of 25.5 percent across the enterprise while saving military families approximately $1.58 billion.

The bottom line is that DeCA saved American military families much more money than it cost American taxpayers. No other entitlement in the military system has a positive ROI — where the benefit exceeds its cost! This is a great argument for maintaining the benefit. By contrast, privatizing the commissaries would eliminate this incredible outcome, while reducing the quality of life for our military families and negatively impacting recruiting and retention of our military.

William F. (Bill) Moore served as Director and Chief Executive Officer of the Defense Commissary Agency from August 3, 2020, until his retirement on March 31, 2024. The son of an Army combat veteran, non-commissioned officer, he was appointed to the Senior Executive Service in October 2006. His prior assignment was as Assistant Deputy Chief of Staff at U.S. Army Headquarters, where he was responsible for Army logistics plans, policy and programs.