Ripon Forum


Vol. 59, No. 6

View Print Edition

In this edition

As America approaches the 250th anniversary of its founding, the relationship between the press and the public has reached a critical juncture.

Picking Up the Pieces

The veteran journalist examines the lack of trust in the media today and offers his thoughts about how his colleagues in the Fourth Estate can win back the confidence of the public.

The Age of Influencers and the Rise of AI

Five years after COVID, it’s as though we live in a completely different media world than we did before. We are living in an age of influencers, and our jobs have changed again.

From Ink-Stained Fingers to Instant Feeds

Today, there is no morning news cycle — only a constant one. A story can spark on a podcast, catch fire on social media, and reach thousands before a traditional outlet even weighs in.

Today’s Communications Leaders are Playing 24/7 Three-Dimensional Chess

Earned media is still important, but catching up quickly is “owned” media — that is, producing one’s own content and distributing it through websites and social media.

James Madison would be Appalled

The Founders understood that free speech is a fundamental freedom on which our democracy rests. Restricting press access runs counter to this principle and violates the First Amendment.

America And The Rise Of Assassination Culture

What’s happening on the internet is shaping and changing America in ways far beyond any of us can easily control — and are only beginning to understand.

When it Comes to AI, the Market for Truth Outperforms the Ministry of Truth

If we want AI to deepen our understanding of reality rather than distort it, we need more freedom, not less. Truth can’t be programmed — it must be discovered through open debate.

Fact Checking in the Age of AI

For the first time in history, users may soon have their own personalized fact-checking agents delivering customized, real-time context without waiting for a newsroom to publish a verdict.

As Authoritarians Invest in Online Censorship, Democracies Must Meet the Challenge

Freedom House found that governments have deployed increasingly advanced and widespread measures to control the digital sphere over the past decade and a half.

Done on the Cheap

This essay originally appeared in the December 2007 edition of The Ripon Forum.

Ripon Profile of Brett Guthrie

Energy & Commerce Committee Chair Brett Guthrie discusses his service in the military & elective office.

Today’s Communications Leaders are Playing 24/7 Three-Dimensional Chess

Managing a modern press shop and the challenges facing communicators today

Chris Ullman

Today, the heads of global communications at major companies have their hands full…it’s 24/7 3D chess. Technology is the primary culprit. The Internet flings news around the world in seconds and allows for content platforms that have marginalized traditional print and broadcast news outlets.

In my first public relations job, 38 years ago, we mailed our news releases to reporters. And there were fewer news outlets, many of which put out “the news” once a day. Under lower competitive pressure, reporters had more time to be thorough and accurate. Not anymore. Today, whether the news is coming from Hong Kong, Paris, or New York, scoops are measured in seconds and immediacy trumps accuracy and thoroughness. This requires communications professionals to rethink how they create “news” and how they distribute it.

Pre-internet, PR people relied almost exclusively on “earned” media (objective news coverage) to get messages to key audiences. Earned media is still important, but catching up quickly is “owned” media: producing one’s own content (marketing videos, commentary) and distributing it through websites and social media (YouTube, X, Instagram).

Earned media is still important, but catching up quickly is “owned” media: producing one’s own content (marketing videos, commentary) and distributing it through websites and social media (YouTube, X, Instagram).

Owned media disintermediating traditional media outlets surely excites PR people, as they can by-pass the long-standing news gatekeepers. I am sympathetic to this view; biased reporting has frustrated me for decades. But the public can suffer as the lines are blurred between corporate propaganda and objective news. More on that in a moment.

The challenge with earned media is getting a story in the first place, then hoping it’s accurate and balanced while crossing your fingers that the right people see/read/hear it. Earned media may be more authentic and objective, but you can’t control it. It’s risky.

“Owned” media, meanwhile, is lower risk: you create the content and send it to your targeted audiences. Two challenges: overcoming the inertia of boredom (most corporate content is dreck) and embracing objectivity while rejecting propaganda. To overcome these challenges, a communications head needs to be innovative and creative in producing content and still convince management and lawyers to sign-off. I recommend the “embrace incrementalism” approach. Innovate a little at a time, affording comfort to the powers that be, while moving toward owned content that audiences find compelling and informative, and maybe even humorous.

I espouse a “content is king” approach — meaning, I don’t necessarily care where content (earned or owned) appears as long as it’s on a legitimate platform (major newspaper, network news, YouTube, or trade publication). This has important implications for a modern communications shop.

Day in and day out you’re: writing original Tweets while judiciously responding to critics on social media; scripting and filming a series of YouTube short videos; drafting the latest Substack commentary for your CEO; and developing a new multi-media feature on your corporate website. That’s a lot, especially when audiences are large and stakes are high.

Hiring the right people for these various tasks requires threading the needle between the excitement of youth and the wisdom of age. At its core, though, is the ability to think and write well – sadly, that’s ever in short supply.  Or you contract it all out to a “content” PR firm. But one-step-removed content production risks being safe and banal, because that’s what most PR firms produce. Whichever path a leader chooses, the content producers need a mandate and license to be creative, otherwise the status quo will prevail.

Leading a global communications team today is hard work. But with talented writers and thinkers, deep understanding of earned and owned media, a spirit of innovation, an ability to persuade, and the trust of the CEO, today’s communications heads can advocate well for their clients through the thicket of what technology has wrought on the media landscape.

Chris Ullman is Founder and President of Ullman Communications, a strategic advisory firm based in Alexandria, VA.