Ripon Forum


Vol. 44, No. 3

View Print Edition

Editor’s Note: In This Edition

For years, fiscal gurus and budgetary experts have been warning us about the long term implications of spending more than we take in. The economy will collapse, they warned. Social Security and other important programs will become unaffordable. The standard of living that millions of people had grown accustomed to will no longer exist. For […]

After the Revolution

U.S. Senator John Thune (R-SD) speaks on America’s dissatisfaction with Obama’s promised revolution of hope and change and what must now be done. “They have learned that change isn’t always for the better. Sometimes it is a return to the failed policies and discredited ideas of the past.”

A Recipe for Economic Disaster

“In order to help keep small businesses on the forefront of the markets, it is critical that leaders in Washington foster an environment that encourages creativity and promotes free enterprise.”

In Memoriam- Art Lifson

Medicare’s Crisis of Accountablility

Accountability seems to be a watchword in Washington these days. It is preached by the President, spoken by the Speaker, and has become a standard component of Democratic rhetoric this year.

Advice for My Party As I Head for the Door

BOB BENNETT“As I look out at the political landscape now, I find plenty of slogans on the Republican side, but not very many ideas.” The concern I have is that ideology and a demand for absolute party purity endangers our ability to govern once we get into office. A personal story – back in 1976, […]

Why Missile Defense Is Still Needed

Some arguments are worth repeating. “Take missile defense. The basic justification for developing this weapon system has not changed much since President Reagan proposed it in 1983. But the threats have changed.”

The Perfect Storm, Part I:

“Congress and the Administration must rein in spending and stabilize federal debt relative to GDP.”

The Perfect Storm, Part II: What the Crisis will Look Like When it Hits

Maya MacGuineas makes predictions about the path our nation is headed and presents an argument on what should be done: “To get out of this mess, and we would ultimately have to do what politicians were trying to avoid—raise taxes and cut spending – but to a much greater degree than we ever would have […]

The Perfect Storm, Part III: While Congress Slept

U.S. Senator Mike Enzi discusses how the failure of Congress to pass the budget is to neglect their duty and responsibility. “The majority leadership of this Congress is not doing something, and it’s running our country’s financial future into the ground.”

The Most Important Governor to Watch

“Voters aren’t stupid. But they often don’t pay attention to the details of public policy, especially at the state level. That’s why, when a forceful political leader comes along and points out the obvious, big things can happen fast.”

Moderates and the Wimp Factor

Lou Zickar, the Ripon Forum’s Editor, challenges moderate Republicans to be tough rather than live up to their reputation of being soft. “To counter this perception, moderate Republicans need to find the fiscal equivalent of a pork rind – something that will let them demonstrate their fiscal resolve and commitment to reducing the national debt.”

The Ripon Profile of Charlie Dent

“As Republicans, we must present a concise and understandable agenda that speaks to the economic and fiscal issues that are currently the greatest concern to the American public. “

Medicare’s Crisis of Accountablility

Accountability seems to be a watchword in Washington these days. It is preached by the President, spoken by the Speaker, and has become a standard component of Democratic rhetoric this year.

But in one important area of government spending, the Democrats have chosen to throw accountability out the door. The area is Medicare. Current law requires that an annual report be issued by April 1st of each year outlining the fiscal health of this program upon which so many seniors rely.

The report is issued by the Medicare and Social Security Trustees, who are appointed by the President and tasked with making sure these programs remain solvent. In recent years, these reports have taken on greater prominence, due in no small part to the fact that baby boomers are retiring and people are concerned about the added financial pressure that will be placed on the Medicare system as a result.

This year, however, the report was not released by April 1st. When asked about the delay, an unnamed source at the White House made a cryptic comment about the report being “obsolete,” before eventually settling on the excuse that the report would be issued once the budgetary impact of the new health care law on the Medicare program could be assessed and taken into account.

This year, however, the report was not released by April 1st. When asked about the delay, an unnamed source at the White House made a cryptic comment about the report being “obsolete”…

Originally, the White House indicated this assessment would occur by June 30th. When that date came and went and no report was issued, rumors began circulating that the date had once again been pushed back — this time to August, a month when Congress will be out of session and the focus of the American people will, in theory, be on something else. Naturally, a good many Americans are concerned about this delay. Many members of Congress are also concerned.

In fact, Senators Judd Gregg (R-NH) and Orrin Hatch (R-UT) wrote to the Obama Administration last month demanding that they release their annual assessment of the program immediately. “The 2009 Medicare Trustees Report laid out a grim assessment of the financial status of the Medicare program,” the pair wrote. “Fueled by an aging population and rising health care costs, Medicare expenditures, according to that report, would rise from 3.2 percent of Gross Domestic Product (GDP) in 2008 to 11.4 percent of GDP in 2083. The 2009 Trustees Report estimated that Medicare’s unfunded liability is $38 trillion over the next 75 years and that it’s Hospital Insurance (HI) Trust Fund is expected to become insolvent in 2017. For Congress to effectively address the critical challenge of Medicare solvency, it must have a complete and accurate assessment of the program’s fiscal position.”

But it’s not just the delay in providing this assessment that has Gregg, Hatch, and many other Americans concerned. It’s the fact that two of the Trustees who are supposed to review and approve it have not yet been appointed to the Medicare Board. Under current law, the annual report is intended to be signed by six trustees. Four of the trustees are administration officials; they are the Secretary of Health and Human Services, the Secretary of Treasury, the Secretary of Labor, and the Commissioner of Social Security.

The other two members of the Medicare Board of Trustees come from outside the Administration and are members of the public. The appointment of these two public trustees dates back to the mid-1980s, when former Democratic Senator Patrick Moynihan of New York advocated their selection as a way to not only increase public confidence in the program, but provide a perspective that was not swayed by the current administration.

At a time when Medicare is under increasing financial pressure, the positions are vacant, and the report that for over 25 years has been providing Americans with a better understanding about the program’s future sits on a shelf somewhere, presumably collecting dust.

Unfortunately, these two public trustees have not yet been appointed by President Obama. At a time when Medicare is under increasing financial pressure, the positions are vacant, and the report that for over 25 years has been providing Americans with a better understanding about the program’s future sits on a shelf somewhere, presumably collecting dust.

Of course, that doesn’t mean the Administration has turned its back on Medicare. In fact, over the July 4th holiday recess, President Obama appointed Sir Donald Berwick as the new Administrator of the program. Typically, Berwick’s appointment would need to be approved by Congress. Because the House and Senate were out of session, this did not occur.

This recess appointment allowed Berwick to avoid answering key questions as to why the annual report on the health of Medicare is being delayed and, more critically, whether the health care reform law is, as some fear, a threat to the long-term solvency of the program.

In the process, it also allowed the President and his Democratic allies to avoid practicing something they have been preaching a lot about these days – accountability.

Billy Pitts is a former aide to the House Republican Leadership and a member of The Ripon Forum’s Editorial Board. Lou Zickar is the Forum’s Editor.